New York City Council Header
Meeting Name: Committee on Public Safety Agenda status: Final
Meeting date/time: 5/25/2016 10:00 AM Minutes status: Final  
Meeting location: Council Chambers - City Hall
Published agenda: Agenda Agenda Published minutes: Minutes Minutes  
Meeting video:  
Attachments: Attachments - Int. No. 639-B, Attachments - Int. No. 662-A, Attachments - Int. No. 1056-A, Attachments - Int. No. 1057-A, Attachments - Int. No. 1058-A, Attachments - Int. No. 1059-A, Attachments - Int. No. 1067-A, Attachments - Int. No. 1070-A, Committee Report
File #Ver.Prime SponsorAgenda #Agenda NoteNameTypeSummaryActionResultAction DetailsMultimedia
            Roll call Not available
Int 0639-2015 *Jumaane D. Williams Proposed Int. No. 639-BCriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of summonses.IntroductionThis bill would require the New York City Police Department to report on the number of criminal summonses and the number of summonses to appear in an authorized tribunal of the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“civil summons”), it issues each quarter. This information would be required to be broken down by the offense charged, the race, age and gender of the person to whom a summons was issued, and the borough and precinct in which the summons was issued. The bill would also require this information to be broken down by the criteria used to determine whether a civil or criminal summons was issued. Such criteria are required pursuant to Proposed Int. No. 1057-A.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 0639-2015 *Jumaane D. Williams  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of summonses.IntroductionThis bill would require the New York City Police Department to report on the number of criminal summonses and the number of summonses to appear in an authorized tribunal of the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“civil summons”), it issues each quarter. This information would be required to be broken down by the offense charged, the race, age and gender of the person to whom a summons was issued, and the borough and precinct in which the summons was issued. The bill would also require this information to be broken down by the criteria used to determine whether a civil or criminal summons was issued. Such criteria are required pursuant to Proposed Int. No. 1057-A.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 0639-2015 *Jumaane D. Williams  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of summonses.IntroductionThis bill would require the New York City Police Department to report on the number of criminal summonses and the number of summonses to appear in an authorized tribunal of the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“civil summons”), it issues each quarter. This information would be required to be broken down by the offense charged, the race, age and gender of the person to whom a summons was issued, and the borough and precinct in which the summons was issued. The bill would also require this information to be broken down by the criteria used to determine whether a civil or criminal summons was issued. Such criteria are required pursuant to Proposed Int. No. 1057-A.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 0639-2015 BJumaane D. Williams  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of summonses.IntroductionThis bill would require the New York City Police Department to report on the number of criminal summonses and the number of summonses to appear in an authorized tribunal of the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“civil summons”), it issues each quarter. This information would be required to be broken down by the offense charged, the race, age and gender of the person to whom a summons was issued, and the borough and precinct in which the summons was issued. The bill would also require this information to be broken down by the criteria used to determine whether a civil or criminal summons was issued. Such criteria are required pursuant to Proposed Int. No. 1057-A.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 0662-2015 *Mark Levine Proposed Int. No. 662-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of desk appearance tickets.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either arrest the offender, issue a desk appearance ticket, or issue either a criminal or civil summons. The difference between a desk appearance and a summons is that issuing a desk appearance ticket requires the offender to be fingerprinted and booked, typically at a police precinct. This bill would require the NYPD to issue a quarterly report on the number of desk appearance tickets issued, disaggregated by the race, gender, and age of the person to whom it was issued, as well as the offense charged and the precinct in which it was issued.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 0662-2015 *Mark Levine  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of desk appearance tickets.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either arrest the offender, issue a desk appearance ticket, or issue either a criminal or civil summons. The difference between a desk appearance and a summons is that issuing a desk appearance ticket requires the offender to be fingerprinted and booked, typically at a police precinct. This bill would require the NYPD to issue a quarterly report on the number of desk appearance tickets issued, disaggregated by the race, gender, and age of the person to whom it was issued, as well as the offense charged and the precinct in which it was issued.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 0662-2015 *Mark Levine  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of desk appearance tickets.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either arrest the offender, issue a desk appearance ticket, or issue either a criminal or civil summons. The difference between a desk appearance and a summons is that issuing a desk appearance ticket requires the offender to be fingerprinted and booked, typically at a police precinct. This bill would require the NYPD to issue a quarterly report on the number of desk appearance tickets issued, disaggregated by the race, gender, and age of the person to whom it was issued, as well as the offense charged and the precinct in which it was issued.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 0662-2015 AMark Levine  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Requiring the police department to submit quarterly reports relating to the issuance of desk appearance tickets.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either arrest the offender, issue a desk appearance ticket, or issue either a criminal or civil summons. The difference between a desk appearance and a summons is that issuing a desk appearance ticket requires the offender to be fingerprinted and booked, typically at a police precinct. This bill would require the NYPD to issue a quarterly report on the number of desk appearance tickets issued, disaggregated by the race, gender, and age of the person to whom it was issued, as well as the offense charged and the precinct in which it was issued.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 1056-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito Proposed Int. No. 1056-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for violating park rules.IntroductionPresently, the violation of any Department of Parks and Recreation (“DPR”) rule is a misdemeanor, with a penalty of up to 90 days in jail and a fine of up to $1,000. This bill changes the penalty for violating such rules to a violation with a maximum penalty of 1 day in jail and a fine of up to $200. The bill also reduces the maximum civil penalty for park violations from $10,000 to $200. The bill also adds a list of prohibitions in parks to the Administrative Code that are punishable by misdemeanor.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1056-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for violating park rules.IntroductionPresently, the violation of any Department of Parks and Recreation (“DPR”) rule is a misdemeanor, with a penalty of up to 90 days in jail and a fine of up to $1,000. This bill changes the penalty for violating such rules to a violation with a maximum penalty of 1 day in jail and a fine of up to $200. The bill also reduces the maximum civil penalty for park violations from $10,000 to $200. The bill also adds a list of prohibitions in parks to the Administrative Code that are punishable by misdemeanor.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 1056-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for violating park rules.IntroductionPresently, the violation of any Department of Parks and Recreation (“DPR”) rule is a misdemeanor, with a penalty of up to 90 days in jail and a fine of up to $1,000. This bill changes the penalty for violating such rules to a violation with a maximum penalty of 1 day in jail and a fine of up to $200. The bill also reduces the maximum civil penalty for park violations from $10,000 to $200. The bill also adds a list of prohibitions in parks to the Administrative Code that are punishable by misdemeanor.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1056-2016 AMelissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for violating park rules.IntroductionPresently, the violation of any Department of Parks and Recreation (“DPR”) rule is a misdemeanor, with a penalty of up to 90 days in jail and a fine of up to $1,000. This bill changes the penalty for violating such rules to a violation with a maximum penalty of 1 day in jail and a fine of up to $200. The bill also reduces the maximum civil penalty for park violations from $10,000 to $200. The bill also adds a list of prohibitions in parks to the Administrative Code that are punishable by misdemeanor.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 1057-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito Proposed Int. No. 1057-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Enforcement of criminal and civil offenses.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either issue a criminal or civil summons, among other options. This bill states the Council has determined that criminal summonses should only be used for certain low-level offenses in limited circumstances, and requires the NYPD to provide guidance to its officers on when to use criminal and civil summonses, and make such guidance public. The bill also adds definitions for terms such as “civil summons” to create uniformity in the use of these terms throughout the Administrative Code.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1057-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Enforcement of criminal and civil offenses.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either issue a criminal or civil summons, among other options. This bill states the Council has determined that criminal summonses should only be used for certain low-level offenses in limited circumstances, and requires the NYPD to provide guidance to its officers on when to use criminal and civil summonses, and make such guidance public. The bill also adds definitions for terms such as “civil summons” to create uniformity in the use of these terms throughout the Administrative Code.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 1057-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Enforcement of criminal and civil offenses.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either issue a criminal or civil summons, among other options. This bill states the Council has determined that criminal summonses should only be used for certain low-level offenses in limited circumstances, and requires the NYPD to provide guidance to its officers on when to use criminal and civil summonses, and make such guidance public. The bill also adds definitions for terms such as “civil summons” to create uniformity in the use of these terms throughout the Administrative Code.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1057-2016 AMelissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Enforcement of criminal and civil offenses.IntroductionIn enforcing misdemeanors and non-criminal offenses, the New York City Police Department (“NYPD”) may either issue a criminal or civil summons, among other options. This bill states the Council has determined that criminal summonses should only be used for certain low-level offenses in limited circumstances, and requires the NYPD to provide guidance to its officers on when to use criminal and civil summonses, and make such guidance public. The bill also adds definitions for terms such as “civil summons” to create uniformity in the use of these terms throughout the Administrative Code.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 1058-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito Proposed Int. No. 1058-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for excessive noise.IntroductionThis bill amends the civil penalties for unreasonable noise for a noncommercial purpose.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1058-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for excessive noise.IntroductionThis bill amends the civil penalties for unreasonable noise for a noncommercial purpose.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 1058-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for excessive noise.IntroductionThis bill amends the civil penalties for unreasonable noise for a noncommercial purpose.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1058-2016 AMelissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for excessive noise.IntroductionThis bill amends the civil penalties for unreasonable noise for a noncommercial purpose.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 1059-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito Proposed Int. No. 1059-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - OATH procedures for certain quality of life offenses.IntroductionThis bill would require that judges at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“OATH”) offer the option to complete community service in lieu of paying civil penalties for “specified violations,” defined as those related to the possession of an open container of alcohol, public urination, littering, one provision of the noise code, and violating most parks rules. This bill would also allow these judges to dismiss these specified offenses in the interest of justice. This bill would require OATH to report on the adjudication of the specified violations. Finally, the bill requires OATH to conduct a yearly analysis of the penalties and judgments imposed on persons for specified violations, to ensure that OATH is not imposing such penalties and judgments in amounts that are disproportionate to the harm caused by the underlying offenses, and to recommend a possible limit on such penalties and judgments where appropriate.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1059-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - OATH procedures for certain quality of life offenses.IntroductionThis bill would require that judges at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“OATH”) offer the option to complete community service in lieu of paying civil penalties for “specified violations,” defined as those related to the possession of an open container of alcohol, public urination, littering, one provision of the noise code, and violating most parks rules. This bill would also allow these judges to dismiss these specified offenses in the interest of justice. This bill would require OATH to report on the adjudication of the specified violations. Finally, the bill requires OATH to conduct a yearly analysis of the penalties and judgments imposed on persons for specified violations, to ensure that OATH is not imposing such penalties and judgments in amounts that are disproportionate to the harm caused by the underlying offenses, and to recommend a possible limit on such penalties and judgments where appropriate.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 1059-2016 *Melissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - OATH procedures for certain quality of life offenses.IntroductionThis bill would require that judges at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“OATH”) offer the option to complete community service in lieu of paying civil penalties for “specified violations,” defined as those related to the possession of an open container of alcohol, public urination, littering, one provision of the noise code, and violating most parks rules. This bill would also allow these judges to dismiss these specified offenses in the interest of justice. This bill would require OATH to report on the adjudication of the specified violations. Finally, the bill requires OATH to conduct a yearly analysis of the penalties and judgments imposed on persons for specified violations, to ensure that OATH is not imposing such penalties and judgments in amounts that are disproportionate to the harm caused by the underlying offenses, and to recommend a possible limit on such penalties and judgments where appropriate.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1059-2016 AMelissa Mark-Viverito  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - OATH procedures for certain quality of life offenses.IntroductionThis bill would require that judges at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“OATH”) offer the option to complete community service in lieu of paying civil penalties for “specified violations,” defined as those related to the possession of an open container of alcohol, public urination, littering, one provision of the noise code, and violating most parks rules. This bill would also allow these judges to dismiss these specified offenses in the interest of justice. This bill would require OATH to report on the adjudication of the specified violations. Finally, the bill requires OATH to conduct a yearly analysis of the penalties and judgments imposed on persons for specified violations, to ensure that OATH is not imposing such penalties and judgments in amounts that are disproportionate to the harm caused by the underlying offenses, and to recommend a possible limit on such penalties and judgments where appropriate.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 1067-2016 *Vanessa L. Gibson Proposed Int. No. 1067-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for possessing an open container of alcohol.IntroductionThis bill adds the possibility of a civil penalty of up to 25 dollars for a violation of the City’s prohibition on possessing an open container of alcohol in public, which would be returnable to the office of administrative trials and hearings. Further, the bill reduces the possible jail penalty for this offense from 5 days to 1 day.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1067-2016 *Vanessa L. Gibson  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for possessing an open container of alcohol.IntroductionThis bill adds the possibility of a civil penalty of up to 25 dollars for a violation of the City’s prohibition on possessing an open container of alcohol in public, which would be returnable to the office of administrative trials and hearings. Further, the bill reduces the possible jail penalty for this offense from 5 days to 1 day.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 1067-2016 *Vanessa L. Gibson  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for possessing an open container of alcohol.IntroductionThis bill adds the possibility of a civil penalty of up to 25 dollars for a violation of the City’s prohibition on possessing an open container of alcohol in public, which would be returnable to the office of administrative trials and hearings. Further, the bill reduces the possible jail penalty for this offense from 5 days to 1 day.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1067-2016 AVanessa L. Gibson  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for possessing an open container of alcohol.IntroductionThis bill adds the possibility of a civil penalty of up to 25 dollars for a violation of the City’s prohibition on possessing an open container of alcohol in public, which would be returnable to the office of administrative trials and hearings. Further, the bill reduces the possible jail penalty for this offense from 5 days to 1 day.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available
Int 1070-2016 *Rory I. Lancman Proposed Int. No. 1070-ACriminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for littering, spitting and public urination.IntroductionThis bill eliminates a section of the Administrative Code relating to the distribution of advertising material that had been found unconstitutional, and adds a subsection relating to spitting in a public space or a stairway of a private building. It also amends the civil penalties for public urination and regular littering by an individual, and reduces the possible jail penalties for these offenses from 10 days to 1 day.Hearing Held by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1070-2016 *Rory I. Lancman  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for littering, spitting and public urination.IntroductionThis bill eliminates a section of the Administrative Code relating to the distribution of advertising material that had been found unconstitutional, and adds a subsection relating to spitting in a public space or a stairway of a private building. It also amends the civil penalties for public urination and regular littering by an individual, and reduces the possible jail penalties for these offenses from 10 days to 1 day.Amendment Proposed by Comm  Action details Not available
Int 1070-2016 *Rory I. Lancman  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for littering, spitting and public urination.IntroductionThis bill eliminates a section of the Administrative Code relating to the distribution of advertising material that had been found unconstitutional, and adds a subsection relating to spitting in a public space or a stairway of a private building. It also amends the civil penalties for public urination and regular littering by an individual, and reduces the possible jail penalties for these offenses from 10 days to 1 day.Amended by Committee  Action details Not available
Int 1070-2016 ARory I. Lancman  Criminal Justice Reform Act (CJRA) - Penalties for littering, spitting and public urination.IntroductionThis bill eliminates a section of the Administrative Code relating to the distribution of advertising material that had been found unconstitutional, and adds a subsection relating to spitting in a public space or a stairway of a private building. It also amends the civil penalties for public urination and regular littering by an individual, and reduces the possible jail penalties for these offenses from 10 days to 1 day.Approved by CommitteePass Action details Not available